Colorado hospitals as an entire remained financially wholesome via the primary two years of the pandemic, however their revenue margins have been slashed in half in 2022 as prices swelled, pushing nearly all of the state’s hospital programs into the crimson by the autumn.
Breaking even or shedding cash for a yr or two may not spell catastrophe for hospitals, significantly for programs that constructed up reserves earlier than COVID-19 hit. However an incapability to show no less than a small revenue over the long run might result in layoffs, diminished well being companies and even hospitals closing.
St. Vincent Hospital in Leadville got here near shutting down final yr, earlier than an infusion of state and native funds pulled it from the brink. Well being programs corresponding to Banner Well being and CommonSpirit Well being — which owns the Catholic hospitals below the Centura partnership, together with St. Anthony in Lakewood — misplaced cash treating sufferers within the first 9 months of 2022.
And Denver Well being’s lack of $34 million final yr, and the actual fact it had lower than 90 days’ money available, led state legislators to approve what was thought-about an “extraordinary” emergency appropriation of $5 million final month to stabilize town’s safety-net hospital.
“It’s staggering. It appears like a punch within the intestine,” Julie Lonborg, spokeswoman for the Colorado Hospital Affiliation, mentioned of the monetary hit the state’s hospitals took in 2022.
State officers see final yr as an anomaly after a protracted stretch of profitability, whereas hospital leaders argue it was yet one more blow to a sector battered by the pandemic and worker burnout. They don’t essentially disagree on the numbers a lot as what these numbers imply — and what “wet day” funds are supposed to do.
Income from treating sufferers for all Colorado hospitals mixed elevated by about $898 million from 2021 to 2022, however care bills grew by $1.7 billion, in accordance with newly launched knowledge from the Colorado Hospital Affiliation.
About half of the rise in bills was for salaries as hospitals hit by excessive turnover have been compelled to spend extra — together with on costlier journey nurses — to fill jobs, and confronted rising prices related to provides, worker advantages, charity care and unhealthy debt.
As a bunch, the state’s hospitals remained worthwhile in 2022, with a couple of 4.7% margin on affected person care, in comparison with 10.6% in 2019. However that narrowed to about 1.5% when funding losses from final yr’s market downturn are included.
The troublesome yr adopted a number of good ones.
After together with pandemic support, Colorado hospitals had about an 8.6% revenue on affected person care in 2020 and a 9.6% margin in 2021. With investments included, the revenue margin was near 14% in each years — although even then, some services fared much better than others, with some small and rural hospitals struggling to interrupt even.
The Colorado Division of Well being Care Coverage and Financing estimated hospitals within the state had a mean revenue of $1,181 per affected person in 2021, even after accounting for charity care and decrease charges paid by Medicare and Medicaid. That was similar to 2019 ranges.
Tom Rennell, senior vice chairman of monetary coverage and knowledge analytics on the Colorado Hospital Affiliation, mentioned 47% of hospitals within the state had adverse margins on affected person care in 2021, up from 41% in 2019. The group considers a 4% margin sustainable, and solely about 44% of hospitals had that in 2021. And that’s earlier than a spike in prices final yr, he mentioned.
Sufferers are staying longer, which will increase prices, however some insurance policy pay a bundled price whatever the size of keep, Rennell mentioned. The hospital affiliation reported working bills in 2022 have been about 21% greater than in 2019, due to elevated prices for wages and provides. Income was up about 12%.
“Revenues definitely aren’t rising that a lot,” he mentioned.
Kim Bimestefer, government director of the Division of Well being Care Coverage and Financing, acknowledged prices have been up final yr, however mentioned more-profitable hospitals can bridge the hole by dipping into reserves, particularly for the reason that price to usher in additional employees is coming down.
“That’s what wet day funds are for,” she mentioned. “Households and employers aren’t sitting on billions of {dollars}.”
Of the seven hospital programs whose reserves the division estimated, just one had lower than $1 billion within the first 9 months of 2022: Denver Well being, which had about $223 million in money available. Whereas that will sound like a big quantity, it equates to about 87 days’ price of expenditures, a stage the place hospital leaders and state officers each begin to get nervous.
Days’ money available represents how lengthy a hospital might function if no new income got here in. Whereas that’s not a practical state of affairs, it offers a way of how a lot cushion a hospital has if funds are late or bills rise. Most programs had fewer days of money available than they did in 2019, even when their reserves elevated, as a result of prices additionally rose.
Colorado lawmakers look like skeptical of the declare hospitals are treading water financially.
Payments launched this spring would restrict how a lot medical suppliers can cost above estimates and cap rates of interest on medical debt; require hospitals to report extra monetary data, together with transfers to headquarters out-of-state and government compensation, with fines for many who don’t comply; and ban “facility charges” for outpatient care in hospital-owned practices.
Colorado isn’t the one state whose lawmakers are speaking about focusing on hospitals. In Indiana, the legislature is contemplating an identical invoice banning some facility charges, and a proposal that will go even additional by penalizing nonprofit hospitals if their costs for industrial insurance policy exceed 260% of what Medicare would pay.
In 2022, 38% of People polled by Gallup mentioned they’d postpone some kind of medical care due to issues about price, and about one-fourth of those that did mentioned it was for a situation they deemed “severe.” About 28% of People who owed medical money owed have been solely indebted to a hospital, whereas one other 45% owed each a hospital and one other kind of supplier, in accordance with a ballot from the Robert Wooden Johnson Basis.
Hospitals account for about 40% of well being care prices, so it’s not doable to decrease the burden on sufferers with out addressing them, Bimestefer mentioned. The speed of price development has dropped from 5% to six% annually to below 3%, which is progress, she mentioned.
“This enterprise isn’t for the faint of coronary heart,” she mentioned. “If you wish to decrease well being care prices, you’re going to must disrupt somebody’s income stream.”
Programs took a success in 2022
Six of the state’s eight hospital programs had adverse revenue margins within the first 9 months of 2022. 5 have been worthwhile when solely affected person care, nevertheless.
Full hospital-level knowledge for 2022 received’t be obtainable till early 2024.
One rural facility, St. Vincent Well being in Leadville, was getting ready to closing in December after posting an almost $2.3 million loss, however was rescued on the final minute by $1.5 million in advances from the state and Lake County. The hospital had taken on prices to develop companies that turned out to be unsustainable and had issues with its accounting software program, which interfered with billing, in accordance with Kaiser Well being Information.
Denver Well being additionally reported a very troublesome yr, with a $39.9 million working loss within the first 9 months of 2022, that means it spent extra on affected person care than it obtained in funds for that care. With funding losses, the drop got here to about $73.8 million.
By yr’s finish, although, Denver Well being’s working loss had improved to $34 million. A year-end complete together with funding losses was not obtainable.
In a abstract for traders in October, Denver Well being attributed the 2022 shortfall to lower-than-expected numbers of sufferers with industrial insurance coverage, which pays the very best charges; higher-than-expected quantities of charity care; decrease affected person volumes total, as a result of some beds have been closed; and continued additional bills to rent journey nurses, who command greater wages than everlasting employees.
“A part of our mission is to serve our neighborhood and supply care no matter their skill to pay,” Denver Well being CEO Donna Lynne mentioned. “There’s a confluence of things in 2022.”
Youngsters’s Hospital Colorado additionally misplaced cash within the first 9 months of 2022, however that was solely from a $180 million drop within the worth of investments. Income from affected person care truly rose to about $70.3 million within the first three quarters of the yr, in comparison with $57.4 million in the identical interval in 2021, as income development outpaced rising bills.
UCHealth additionally took a major hit on funding revenue, in accordance with disclosures to traders. The system got here out forward on affected person care by about $327 million within the fiscal yr ending in June 2022, although bills grew sooner than revenue. That turned an almost $314 million loss when funding fluctuations have been added in, although.
Dan Weaver, spokesman for UCHealth, estimated that compensation prices have been up 21% in 4 years, whereas Medicare reimbursements rose solely 9% and Medicaid funds went up about 4.5%.
The 2 programs that make up Centura Well being, CommonSpirit Well being and AdventHealth, each misplaced cash within the first 9 months of 2022. The Adventist hospitals made a slim revenue of 0.1% on affected person care, whereas CommonSpirit’s Catholic hospitals misplaced about 4.8% on affected person care.
The one two programs that made cash total within the first 9 months of 2022 have been HealthOne, which posted a 9.4% complete revenue margin, and SCL Well being, which had a 15.1% margin. SCL, which was bought by Utah-based Intermountain Healthcare final yr, had greater earnings than in 2021, whereas HealthOne’s have been down.
Marilyn Bartlett, senior coverage fellow on the Heart for Well being System Prices, mentioned that hospitals probably noticed an enchancment within the last quarter of the yr, as labor prices began to lower and the inventory market recovered.
“We now have seen a turnaround,” she mentioned. “2023 seems to be higher.”
Questions on investments, “wet day funds”
State officers and the Colorado Hospital Affiliation differed on whether or not services’ funding portfolios ought to be used to guage hospitals’ funds.
Rennell mentioned the hospital affiliation focuses on working revenue — the income from taking good care of sufferers — as a result of investments may be unstable.
“As quickly because the inventory market goes adverse, these numbers go adverse,” he mentioned.
The Division of Well being Care Coverage and Financing defended together with the funding numbers in its calculations.
“For some programs like Denver Well being, non-operating earnings may be the distinction between earnings and losses. For a lot of huge programs, non-operating earnings enhance and even double their earnings,” the division mentioned in an announcement.
It’s true that calculations may be “tough” as a result of funding revenue fluctuates, mentioned Allan Baumgarten, an analyst who has studied Colorado’s well being care market. Nonetheless, it’s actual cash that ought to be accounted for as a part of the larger image, he mentioned.
“It’s important to take a look at the outcomes not only one yr at a time, however the final 5 to seven years,” he mentioned.
Rennell mentioned funding revenue and reserves will let hospitals so as to add capability and staff sooner or later, whereas permitting them to get higher rates of interest when they should borrow cash now. He doesn’t see these targets as being in stress with controlling care prices.
“Such as you and me, they’re saving for the long run,” he mentioned. “Our hospitals are doing rather a lot to attempt to handle prices and keep companies for Coloradans.”
Nancy Dolson, the Division of Well being Care Coverage and Financing’s particular financing division director, mentioned there’s no set normal for the way a lot money hospitals ought to have in reserves, however 9 months’ to 1 yr’s price is usually seen as cheap. Denver Well being’s decline in money available is regarding, and UCHealth had a major drop, although that was largely attributable to funding losses and repaying loans from Medicare, she mentioned.
“We see the wet day funds weren’t used as a lot as could be anticipated with the pandemic,” she mentioned.
The true significance of reserves is to indicate potential bond consumers {that a} hospital has loads of money available and is an effective wager, which permits it to get higher bond scores when it desires to develop, Baumgarten mentioned. Whether or not that aligns with sufferers’ pursuits is determined by if there’s want further companies in any given space, or if hospitals are simply attempting to get an even bigger share of the market by providing extra facilities, he mentioned.
“The foremost purpose of those organizations is to proceed rising,” he mentioned. “However someone has to pay the payments.”
Tom Gronow, president and CEO of College of Colorado Hospital, pushed again on the concept sufferers don’t profit from programs’ increasing their attain. Having a presence all through the state reduces the necessity to carry individuals to the Aurora campus, which has the very best prices due to the complexity of care provided, he mentioned.
“Folks say it’s development for development’s sake,” he mentioned. “It’s truly development so we will affect the price of care.”
Hospitals have introduced their prices down, in order that Colorado was now not one of many high 10 states by way of how costly it’s to ship care as of 2021, Dolson mentioned. Nonetheless, the state had the sixth-highest costs charged within the nation, and the fourth-highest complete earnings and earnings per affected person, she mentioned.
“We see enchancment in price of care, however and not using a discount in worth,” she mentioned.
Worthwhile pandemic years for some (however not all)
Colorado hospitals as a bunch have been worthwhile in 2020 and 2021, partially attributable to one-time funds to offset the results of the pandemic. Even with stimulus {dollars}, nevertheless, there was vital variation. Denver Well being eked out a slim 1.2% revenue margin in 2021, whereas UCHealth had a 16.5% margin, in accordance with the division.
Normally, unbiased hospitals have been much less worthwhile than programs, and rural hospitals have been much less worthwhile than city ones, which is in step with the sample nationwide. The highest 5 hospitals that made the most important earnings on affected person care in Colorado have been a part of programs, and 4 of them have been within the Denver space. The exception was Centura St. Anthony Summit Hospital in Frisco.
Three of the 5 with the most important losses on affected person care have been unbiased rural services, however two have been within the metro space. And when funding revenue is counted in, UCHealth had three of the most-profitable hospitals, but additionally 4 of the least worthwhile. Weaver mentioned the system’s newer hospitals have provided decrease costs, resulting in decrease earnings.
Rural unbiased hospitals had a median of 215 days’ money available — that means half had extra and half had much less — whereas city hospitals and people in programs had a median of 245 days’ price in 2021. It ranged from a low of 71 days at Delta Well being to 527 days at Vail Valley Medical Heart.
Rural hospitals suffered extra when states shut down elective care within the early days of the pandemic, as a result of nonemergency surgical procedures and outpatient procedures account for a bigger share of their income, Baumgarten mentioned. They already confronted a number of headwinds, together with fewer sufferers lined by industrial insurance coverage and restricted skill to barter greater charges, which have been then compounded by inflation and shifts in how individuals obtained care.
“That was a a lot larger hit to their funds than a few of the bigger hospitals,” he mentioned.
Kevin Stansbury, CEO of Lincoln Well being in Hugo, mentioned the federal COVID-19 stimulus funding obtained rural hospitals via the worst of the pandemic, however didn’t change the underlying issues they face. As a result of they serve small populations, it’s troublesome to cowl the overhead prices of staying open across the clock, not to mention save up cash to exchange getting old services, he mentioned.
“We have to work out a technique to have a sustainable margin,” he mentioned.
Join our weekly publication to get well being information despatched straight to your inbox.
